Lately, I’ve been having a lot of conversations with nonprofit leaders who are navigating big transitions.
Staff departures. Role changes. Shifting priorities. Uncertainty about what comes next.
And I’ve been struck by something. The leaders who are handling these moments best aren’t the ones who have everything figured out. They’re the ones who are willing to be honest about the fact that they don’t.
At the same time, in my own life, I’ve been navigating some unexpected changes: plans that have been upended, losses that hit harder than expected, moments where I had to admit that I needed help.
And I’ve realized something that applies both professionally and personally:
Courageous leadership isn’t about pushing through without acknowledging the hard parts.
It’s about showing up with intention, honesty, and authenticity, even when things feel uncertain.
Here are seven ways to do that.
1. Name What’s Real (Even When It’s Uncomfortable)
In times of change, people can tell when something is off. Trying to smooth things over or present a perfectly polished version of reality usually backfires. The leaders I’ve admired most lately have been willing to say things like:
- “This is a big transition.”
- “We don’t have all the answers yet.”
- “This is both an opportunity and a challenge.”
That kind of honesty builds trust. It also creates space for real conversations, instead of speculation or anxiety filling the gaps.
2. Hold Both Truths at Once
One of the most powerful leadership skills is the ability to hold complexity. Something can be:
- Exciting and unsettling
- Full of opportunity and full of risk
- A step forward and a loss
When leaders acknowledge both sides, it gives everyone else permission to feel what they’re feeling, without needing to resolve it immediately.
3. Don’t Wait Until You’re Certain to Communicate
There’s a temptation to hold off on communicating until everything is “figured out.” But in fast-moving or uncertain situations, that moment rarely comes. Silence can feel like avoidance, even when it’s not.
Sharing what you do know (and what you don’t yet know) keeps people grounded and connected. It also reinforces that leadership is happening in real time, not behind closed doors.
4. Lead with Questions, Not Just Answers
Courageous leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about being willing to ask the right questions:
- What do we need most right now?
- What are we not talking about that we should be?
- Where do we need support?
In nonprofit organizations, especially, where teams are often stretched thin, creating space for input can surface better ideas and stronger buy-in.
5. Let Yourself Be Seen (Appropriately)
There’s a version of leadership that says you should always appear steady, composed, and unshakable. But that’s not what people actually need. They need leaders who are real. That doesn’t mean oversharing or making everything about you. But it does mean being willing to say:
- “This has been hard.”
- “I’m navigating this, too.”
- “I don’t have all the answers, but I’m committed to working through it.”
That kind of vulnerability creates connection… and, often, relief.
6. Normalize Asking for Help
This is one I’ve been working on personally.
When things get difficult, it’s easy to default to handling everything on your own. But asking for help is not a failure of leadership. It’s a demonstration of it. Whether it’s leaning on your team’s expertise, reaching out to peers or advisors, or just saying “I could use some help,” you model something powerful when you do this.
7. Stay Grounded in Intention, Not Perfection
In times of uncertainty, it’s easy to second-guess every decision. To wonder if you’re getting it exactly right. But courageous leadership isn’t about perfection. It is (in part) about intention:
- Are you acting with integrity?
- Are you communicating honestly?
- Are you making thoughtful decisions with the information you have?
Final Thought
We often think of courage as bold, decisive action. And sometimes it is. At other times, courage looks like something quieter:
- Telling the truth
- Admitting uncertainty
- Asking for help
- Staying present when things feel hard
That kind of leadership builds trust, resilience, and stronger relationships along the way.
Don’t miss out on new ideas and great tips on fundraising, leadership, writing, philanthropy, and lots of related topics. Join the PITCH list to get Lauren’s monthly newsletter delivered straight to your inbox, and get a free gift when you sign up!