Is This Fundraising Opportunity Really Worth It?
Nonprofit organizations are constantly presented with fundraising opportunities. Some are an easy yes. Some are an easy no. And some fall into that murky middle where the opportunity looks great on paper—but your gut is quietly asking whether the cost will outweigh the benefit.
Let’s start with the obvious.
If your organization runs an afterschool children’s art program, you should not start a teen ultimate frisbee league just because funding is available. That’s not strategy. That’s mission creep.
But many decisions aren’t that clear-cut—especially when a large grant or donation is involved.
I’ve written before about deciding whether a small grant is worth pursuing. But what about a big one? Is every big fundraising opportunity worth chasing?
Without apology or regret, my answer is: no.
Here are several questions to ask before saying yes.
1. Is the opportunity truly mission-aligned?
Ask yourself honestly:
- Do we already do the work that would be funded by this new opportunity?
- Do we do it well?
- Would we want to continue this work if the funding went away?
Fundraising should strengthen your mission, not pull it sideways.
2. How heavy is the lift?
Every fundraising opportunity has a cost before a single dollar is awarded.
Consider:
- How much staff time will the application require?
- Will you need new data, partners, budgets, or approvals?
- What are the reporting requirements—and how frequent and complex are they?
If pursuing this opportunity means “stop everything else so we can focus on this,” it deserves extra scrutiny.
3. What’s your likelihood of success?
Hope is not a strategy.
If an application is extremely time-intensive and your chances of success are around 10%, think carefully. That doesn’t mean you should never take a long shot—but you should be clear-eyed about what else will stall while you do.
- How competitive is this opportunity?
- Do we clearly meet both eligibility requirements and stated priorities?
- Are we realistically positioned to rise to the top?
4. Is there value beyond the dollar amount?
Sometimes a grant looks like too much work for too little money… until you zoom out.
For example:
- Is this a prestigious funder whose support could attract other donors?
- Does this funding help fulfill a strategic commitment or partnership?
- Does it allow you to pilot a program you’ve considered making core?
Not all value shows up on a budget line.
5. Is there long-term potential?
Before pursuing a one-time gift, ask what happens next.
- Could this lead to a longer-term donor relationship?
- Will it help diversify funding sources?
- Does it move your organization toward greater sustainability?
Short-term money that creates long-term strain is rarely worth it.
The real cost of never saying “no”
Saying no can be uncomfortable, especially in a sector conditioned to be grateful for every opportunity.
But not saying no can be far more damaging.
Chasing every fundraising opportunity often leads to:
- Staff stress and burnout
- Mission creep
- Resentment among staff and clients
- Reactive, unfocused work
Not every good opportunity is the right opportunity for your organization, right now.
Discernment isn’t a lack of ambition.
It’s leadership.
Don’t miss out on new ideas and great tips on fundraising, leadership, writing, philanthropy, and lots of related topics. Join the PITCH list to get Lauren’s monthly newsletter delivered straight to your inbox, and get a free gift when you sign up!